Few ideas are as woven into American culture as self-reliance, and July, with its celebrations of independence, is a natural time to think about it. But the popular image of the self-reliant person, the lone figure who needs nothing and no one, is not quite what the idea’s champions described. It is also not a very useful model for anyone rebuilding a life. Here are four common myths and the facts behind them.
Myth: Self-reliance is mostly about practical toughness
Fact: The phrase owes much of its fame to Ralph Waldo Emerson’s 1841 essay “Self-Reliance.” Emerson’s main concern was not chopping your own wood. It was independent thinking: trusting your own judgment and conscience instead of simply following custom or crowd opinion. Practical skills are valuable, but the heart of the idea is the courage to think for yourself and live by what you believe.
Myth: Thoreau lived in total isolation at Walden
Fact: Emerson’s friend Henry David Thoreau famously moved into a small cabin at Walden Pond on July 4, 1845, and the book he wrote about the experience became a classic of simple, deliberate living. But the cabin stood on land Emerson owned, within walking distance of the town of Concord. Thoreau went into town often, received visitors and wrote about them. His experiment was about living simply and paying attention, not about cutting himself off from people. Even one of the most famous symbols of American independence stayed connected to a community.
Myth: Freedom means keeping all your options open
Fact: Keeping every door open can feel like independence, but it can also keep you stuck in the hallway. Freedom includes the ability to choose a direction and commit to it. A person who signs up for a race, starts a business or promises to show up for a friend every week is using their independence, not giving it up. The commitments worth questioning are the ones you never really chose.
Myth: Independence is something you achieve once
Fact: Independence shifts across a lifetime. A move, an illness, a divorce, a new baby, a job loss or simply getting older can change what you can do on your own and what you need help with. Accepting support during one season does not erase your independence. Often it is what allows you to regain it. Different kinds of independence also grow at different speeds:
- Practical skills, like cooking, simple repairs or handling paperwork.
- Financial understanding, with guidance from a qualified professional when the stakes are high.
- Decision-making, starting with small choices and working up.
- Emotional steadiness, including knowing when to reach out.
A better definition
A healthier picture of self-reliance looks something like this: you think for yourself, you take responsibility for your choices, you keep building your abilities and you invest in relationships you can count on, in both directions. That kind of independence does not isolate you. It makes you a stronger part of everything you belong to.
As the country celebrates its independence this month, consider which part of your own could use some attention, and choose one small skill to practice before August.
New messages, real moments from the road, and the All Is Well Project. Follow along and say hello.
The lessons behind everything Chris teaches. Start with three chapters, free.
Turn the lessons into your comeback.
Talk it through free with the Team Dorrity coach, or work with Chris one-on-one in The Better Than Back Experience.
