April begins with a day devoted to fooling other people. The rest of the year, most of us spend a surprising amount of effort fooling ourselves. After a setback especially, the mind becomes a skilled storyteller, and not all of its stories are true. Some protect us from pain we are not ready to face. Others keep us stuck. Learning to spot the difference is one of the quieter skills of a real comeback.
Why the mind tells stories
A setback creates a gap between how things were supposed to go and how they went. The mind hates that gap and rushes to fill it with an explanation. The explanation becomes a story, and the story shapes what we do next. This is useful when the story is accurate. It is costly when the story is built to protect our feelings rather than to describe reality.
None of this is a character flaw. Everyone does it. The question is whether you are willing to look at your own stories with the same skepticism you would apply to someone else’s.
The common fictions
A few stories appear again and again after setbacks:
- It was entirely their fault. This one protects the ego but prevents learning, because there is nothing for you to change.
- It was entirely my fault. This sounds like accountability but is often a way of avoiding the harder work of sorting out what was actually yours to own.
- This is just how I am. A story that turns a situation into an identity, so that change seems pointless.
- Everything was fine until this happened. Usually, the setback revealed problems that were already there.
- Once I get past this, everything will be good again. A comforting story that postpones living until some future date.
Each of these has a grain of truth, which is what makes it convincing. None is the whole picture.
How to test a story
Treat your explanation of the setback as a hypothesis rather than a fact. Then ask a few questions. What evidence supports this story, and what evidence have I been ignoring? How would a fair observer who likes me, but is not me, describe what happened? What would I have to believe about myself if this story were not true, and is that belief what I am avoiding?
It also helps to write the story down and read it a week later. Stories that felt airtight in the heat of the moment often look obviously partial after a little distance.
The useful kind of story
Not all storytelling is self-deception. A good story about a setback is honest about what happened, fair about who contributed what, specific about what can be learned and open about what comes next. It does not flatter you and it does not condemn you. It leaves room for you to act.
The test is simple: does the story make you more capable or less? A true story may hurt, but it almost always hands you something to do. A protective fiction feels better and leaves you exactly where you were.
Getting outside help with the narrative
Self-deception is hard to catch alone, by definition. Trusted friends who will tell you the truth are invaluable here, and so are mentors who have seen similar situations. If the stories you are telling yourself are persistently harsh, or if you find yourself unable to see the setback as anything but proof of your own worthlessness, a counselor can help you build a more accurate and more livable account.
The first of April is a fine day to be fooled by someone else, briefly, for a laugh. The rest of the year, the most useful thing you can do is refuse to be fooled by yourself.
New messages, real moments from the road, and the All Is Well Project. Follow along and say hello.
The lessons behind everything Chris teaches. Start with three chapters, free.
Turn the lessons into your comeback.
Talk it through free with the Team Dorrity coach, or work with Chris one-on-one in The Better Than Back Experience.
