Grit gets a lot of praise, and deservedly so. The ability to keep going when things are hard is at the heart of every comeback. But persistence has an evil twin. Stubbornness looks almost identical from the outside, feels like strength from the inside, and quietly wrecks plans that should have changed long ago. Telling the two apart is one of the most valuable judgments you can learn to make.
They feel the same but point in different directions
Both grit and stubbornness involve refusing to quit. The difference is what you are refusing to quit on. Grit is loyalty to a goal. Stubbornness is loyalty to a method, a position or an image of yourself. A gritty person wants to reach the destination and will change the route as many times as necessary. A stubborn person wants to be right about the route and will keep driving into the same wall to prove it.
Five questions to ask yourself
- Have I learned anything new since I made this decision? Grit updates with information. Stubbornness ignores it.
- Can I explain why this approach is still the best one, in terms someone else would accept? If your only argument is that you have already come this far, that is a warning sign.
- What would I tell a friend in exactly my position? Stubbornness is much easier to spot in other people.
- Am I persisting toward something or away from something? Persisting to avoid admitting a mistake is not grit.
- Have trusted people told me to reconsider, and have I actually considered it, or just defended myself?
Why stubbornness is so convincing
Stubbornness survives because it borrows the language of virtue. It calls itself determination, commitment and loyalty. It points to stories of people who ignored the doubters and triumphed, forgetting the far larger number who ignored the doubters and did not. It also feeds on sunk costs: the more you have invested in a path, the more painful it is to admit the path was wrong, so you keep investing.
Pride plays a part too. Changing course can feel like a public admission that the critics were right. Grit does not care about the critics. It cares about the goal.
What grit looks like in practice
Gritty people tend to share a few habits. They set review points in advance, dates on which they will honestly assess whether the approach is working. They separate their identity from their methods, so changing a method is not a blow to the self. They seek out people who will disagree with them. And they distinguish between hard, which is expected, and futile, which is a signal.
They also quit things, sometimes often. What they do not quit is the underlying aim. A gritty job seeker may abandon an industry, a strategy or a city while never abandoning the goal of meaningful work.
A practical rule
If you are not sure which one you are showing, try this. Commit to the current approach for a defined period, say thirty days, and name in advance what evidence would convince you to change. Then keep your word on both sides: persist fully during the period, and change honestly if the evidence arrives. That rule honors grit without giving stubbornness anywhere to hide.
Persistence is a tool, not a personality. Used in service of a goal, it is one of the best tools there is. Used in service of pride, it is just a slow way of losing.
New messages, real moments from the road, and the All Is Well Project. Follow along and say hello.
The lessons behind everything Chris teaches. Start with three chapters, free.
Turn the lessons into your comeback.
Talk it through free with the Team Dorrity coach, or work with Chris one-on-one in The Better Than Back Experience.
